If you have been looking for a new pair of binoculars or spotting scope, you have probably seen brightness and/or twilight factors reported with the various specifications and in reviews.
Both values are useful if you understand what the numbers mean and under what situations they can be used.
Relative brightness is a theoretical estimation of how bright the image should be when viewed through binoculars or spotting scopes. It is calculated by simply squaring the exit pupil value. The exit pupil is the size of the beam of light that comes out into your eye. Sometimes, this value is also reported with the binocular or spotting scope specifications, but it is also easily calculated by dividing the size of the objective lens by the magnification.
For example (see Table 1), an 8 x 50 (8 power magnification and 50 mm objective lens) binocular has an exit pupil value of 6.25 (50/8). Compare that to 10 X 50 pair of binoculars, where 50/10= 5.0 exit pupil. Then square each exit pupil value to get relative brightness values of 37.5 for the 8 X 50 and 25.0 for the 10 X 50 binoculars. The 10 X 50s have only 67% of the relative brightness of the 8 X 50 binoculars.
Table 1. Exit Pupil and Relative Brightness Calculations for Common Binocular Sizes
|Mag. & Objective||Equation 1||Exit Pupil||Equation 2||Rel. Brightness||Rel. to 8×50|
|8 x 50||50/8 =||6.25||6.25 x 6.25 =||37.5||1.00|
|10 x 50||50/10 =||5.0||5.0 x 5.0 =||25.0||0.67|
|12 x 50||50/12 =||4.17||4.17 x 4.17 =||17.4||0.46|
|8 x 42||42/8 =||5.25||5.25 x 5.25 =||27.6||0.74|
|10 x 42||42/10 =||4.2||4.2 x 4.2 =||17.6||0.47|
|8 x 32||32/8 =||4.0||4.0 x 4.0 =||16.0||0.43|
|10 x 32||32/10 =||3.2||3.2 x 3.2 =||10.2||0.27|
In table 1, you can see relative brightness values for several sizes of binoculars. I also included the ratio of each value to the 8 x 50 binoculars for comparison.
You will notice that as magnification increases and/or as objective lens size becomes smaller, the relative brightness values decrease as light is lost. In the table, the 8 x 50 binoculars will have the brightest image and the 10 x 32s will have the darkest image.
Twilight factor is a theoretical estimation of how much detail can be seen in low light and is estimated by first multiplying the magnification by the objective lens size, and then taking the square root of that product. So twilight factor can increase with an increase of either magnification and objective lens size or both. The twilight factor can also remain the same if the magnification is doubled but the objective size is cut in half (and vice versa).
For example, the 8 X 50 binoculars would be 8 times 50 =400, then the square root of 500 = 20.0 value for twilight factor. The twilight factor for the 10 X 50 is simply 10 times 50 = 500 and the the square root of 500 = 22.4, so the 10 X 50s have a 12% detail advantage over the 8 X 50s in low light.
Table 2. Twilight Factor Calculations for Common Binocular Sizes
|Mag. & Objective||Equation||Twilight Factor||Rel. to 12×50|
|8 x 50||sq. root (8 x 50) =||20.0||0.82|
|10 x 50||sq. root (10 x 50) =||22.4||0.91|
|12 x 50||sq. root (12 x 50) =||24.5||1.00|
|8 x 42||sq. root (8 x 42) =||18.3||0.75|
|10 x 42||sq. root (10 x 42) =||20.5||0.84|
|8 x 32||sq. root (8 x 32) =||16.0||0.65|
|10 x 32||sq. root (10 x 42) =||17.9||0.73|
In table 2, the twilight factor has bee calculated for several sizes of binoculars. I also included the ratio of each value to the 12 x 50 binoculars for comparison. You will notice that as magnification decreases and as the objective lens becomes smaller, the twilight factor decrease as detail is lost. In the table, the 12 x 50s will show the most detail in low light and the 8 x 32s will have the least detail.
How to Use Relative Brightness and Twilight factors
Remember that both the relative brightness and twilight factors are theoretical, so we have to be careful about using these values to make comparisons between different brands and styles of binoculars or spotting scopes. If we want to compare optics of similar quality and style, then theory and reality can be nearly equal and we can get a good idea of which models should have better light gathering ability or ability to see detail in low light conditions. So both of these values are very useful for comparing different magnifications and objective lenses of the same brand and model.
But if you try comparing cheap optics with good quality optics, then theory and reality part company. If you test this in the field, you will see that high quality binoculars gather more light than cheaper binoculars even when the brightness numbers tell you they should be about the same. You will also see more detail in low light with quality binoculars than less expensively built binoculars.
Roof Prism vs Poro Prism Binoculars
Roof prism binoculars are very popular today because of the smaller size and streamlined shape, but that design is inherently more expensive than the classic poro prism designs.
Also be aware that low light conditions accentuates the imperfections of our vision. As it gets darker, our pupils begin to dilate which allows more scattered light to enter the eye. This causes images to be fuzzy. If our vision is a little “fuzzy” in bright light, then it will be more fuzzy in twilight conditions. That is why young eyes with poor quality binoculars can sometimes see better in low light than old eyes using very expensive binoculars.
Costs of Quality Optics
The reasons that higher quality optics gather more light and allow you to see more detail in low light conditions is the use of higher quality glass, coatings, mirrors and all parts are aligned more precisely. Quality parts and construction can transmit more light than poorer quality glass, coatings or poor alignment.
Light is lost as it is absorbed by imperfections in the glass and coatings and is also lost with poor quality mirrors and imperfect alignment within the binoculars. Quality glass, coatings, mirrors and precise alignment costs money.
Highest Quality, Best of the Best Binoculars
The highest quality and binoculars are also usually the most expensive as they attempt to push the technological boundaries of glass, mirrors and coatings. For those that are curious about the absolute best quality binoculars: